Swindon Advertiser – Wind turbines in the limelight of Wyvern stage

Swindon Advertiser today ran an article about the latest development in the Honda Wind Turbine development story

THE Wyvern Theatre will host a very different kind of cabaret next month as members of the council’s planning committee take to the stage.

It has been selected as the venue for a one-off meeting to decide whether to accept plans for three giant wind turbines at the Honda site at South Marston.

The proposals have sparked a groundswell of public anger, with the last meeting being called off for safety reasons because of too many protesters trying to cram into the council chamber.

So the 635 capacity theatre, more accustomed to hosting plays and musicals, will be used instead – and it promises to be ‘quite a show’ said one campaigner.

Andy West, 44, who lives at Kingsdown Park, near the proposed turbines, is worried yet more space will be needed.

“The last meeting had to be deferred because they couldn’t fit them in, and with the Wyvern I think they’d be struggling to fit the people in,” he said.

“Take all the people at the last meeting, all the people who didn’t sign in, and then you’ve got council officers and committee members. You’re up to 600 before you start.”

Ill Wind, the group campaigning against the turbines, is still calling for people to turn up.

“As long as people can participate in what’s going on it is fine. What we don’t want is a situation where the council is trying to close the door on hundreds of people outside,” said Andy.

“It should be quite an interesting day, I would have thought. It’s going to be quite a show.”

Although the venue and date have not been formally rubber-stamped, planning committee chairman Dale Heenan (Con, Covingham and Nythe) said it was expected to be September 8.

Security will be present on the evening, and doors open at 5pm. Seating will be on a first-come, first-served basis.

Speakers will be able to hold the floor for up to three minutes, but with more than 30 registered speakers at the last meeting, it looks set to be a long night.

Marketing manager Gina Banks, 44, of Highworth Road, said: “I’m not surprised. I think it sends a very strong message to the council, so many people are concerned about this application. For me, this isn’t an argument against Honda, Ecotricity, or wind energy. The issue is the proximity to our houses of this application.”

The wind turbines will be the only item on the agenda.

It was 10 years ago that the council had to use the Wyvern as a meeting place. Then it was also for a planning meeting to discuss Wichelstowe.

The Wyvern did not have anything booked on September 8, so no performances had to be cancelled or moved.

Advertiser: We’re not nimbys but we don’t want turbines here

A wind turbine at Greenpark, Reading, England,...

Image via Wikipedia

Swindon Advertiser today ran the latest article regarding Hand/Ecotricity’s planning application for three wind turbines on the Honda site.

The controversial plan to put three turbines at the Honda plant, in South Marston, will come before the council’s planning committee on July 12.

There has been a campaign against the proposals since they were unveiled last summer, and lobby group Ill Wind intends to fill the council chamber when it is debated.

The full article is available here.

Illwind Update – May 2011

Honda/Ecotricity Wind Turbine Application

There is no definite date for the application to return to the Planning Committee, but we will of course let you know as soon as we hear (the earliest possible date is 7th June).

In the meantime, we are facing a serious new threat: Read more of this post

Advertiser – New windfarm rules upset Swindon residents

Wind turbines (Vendsyssel, Denmark)

Image via Wikipedia

Swindon Advertiser, yesterday met with members of Ill Wind to discuss some changes to Swindon Borough Councils Core Strategy. Below is the resulting article:

CAMPAIGNERS are fearful that liberal new rules threaten to open the door for building more wind turbines around Swindon.

The objectors claim obscure changes buried deep in Swindon Council’s Core Strategy would mean that tight planning rules about where turbines can go will be replaced with a soft-touch set of guidelines. Read more of this post

Advertiser – Delay in decision pleases campaigners

Swindon Advertiser today reported on the outcome of last nights planning meeting regarding Honda’s Wind Turbine application.

CAMPAIGNERS were able to breathe a sigh of relief as controversial proposals to build three 120 metre wind turbines were not given the go ahead last night.

Councillors on the Swindon Council planning committee voted seven against six for a motion to defer the application from Honda and sustainable energy firm Ecotricity for another month.

This will allow officers to provide more evidence in relation to the objections of ward councillors and residents.

Coun Dale Heenan (Con, Covingham and Nythe) proposed the motion to defer after hearing from representatives of Ecotricity, Honda and local residents.

He requested the council planning department produce a report setting out the legal grounds for refusal of the application.

“I don’t think we have the information to make a considered view,” he said.

Grant Macpherson, a director of Honda UK, said he hoped the application would be granted as it would help the firm achieve environmental targets.

He said: “The target for Honda in Swindon is a further reduction in CO2 emissions by 24 per cent by 2020. Some may say the application is controversial but all of us at some point are going to have to accept our responsibilities.”

Opposition to the plan has grown since it was announced last summer, with campaigners saying that each electricity-generating turbine would be almost the size of the 135m London Eye Ferris wheel.

Last night more than 100 people with ‘No’ placards gathered in the council chamber at the Civic Offices, in Euclid Street, to hear the decision.

Hazel Beaver, a South Marston resident and member of protest group Ill Wind, asked the committee to consider residents’ feeling against the proposal, saying: “Please recognise the strength of local opposition.

“We have got over 1,800 names on a petition and there have been nearly 400 personal letters sent to the planning department.

“We want Swindon Council to play safe with its residents’ health.

Coun Russell Holland (Con, St Margaret) said that if the committee were to grant planning permission it would open the doors to other wind turbine applications.

He said: “You would be setting a precedent here. As long as you have conditions you can build them where ever you want.

“It’s wrong for Swindon and the recommendations are built on shaky conditions. The residents are clearly right.”

Advertiser – “We don’t want these turbines”

Scott D’Arcy of Swindon Advertiser today posted an article regarding Ill Wind’s submission of the petition against the Wind Turbine planning application.

PROTESTERS against Honda’s plan to build three wind turbines have collected 1,800 names on a petition.

Members of the campaign group Ill Wind, which formed last summer to oppose the proposal for three 120m-high wind turbines at the car manufacturer’s South Marston plant, presented the list of names to Swindon Council ahead of a planning meeting next week.

The application, submitted by Honda in conjunction with energy firm Ecotricity, has suffered several setbacks and fierce opposition from residents in neighbouring Stratton St Margaret and South Marston.

It was initially due to go before the council’s planning committee in October last year but concerns were raised by the Ministry of Defence (MoD) that the turbines might interfere with its radar.

Residents’ main concerns centred around noise levels, ‘shadow flicker’ and the height of the turbines.

But an Ecotricity spokesman said the three turbines combined would produce enough electricity to power 5,300 homes a year.

Andrew Davidson, 59, and Kay Long, 58, both of South Marston, presented the petition yesterday and said there was strong feeling among locals.

Mr Davidson said: “We are hoping that this will convey the strength of feeling with which people oppose this application.

“The nearest one is within 325 metres of a dwelling and they will overpower people’s homes and gardens and cause a huge and unnecessary detriment to them.

“It is absolutely not a case of nimbyism – we already have an industrial estate nearby.

“And we wouldn’t have a problem if these were the same size as the ones at Watchfield.

“Green energy is excellent as long as it is in the right place and these turbines are arguably not the right form of green energy anyway.

Mrs Long said: “Around two thirds of the signatures actually come from Stratton and the strength of feeling on the doorstep is very strong.

A spokesman for Honda said: “We are confident that our submitted application contains all the necessary detailed information needed by Swindon Borough Council to make an informed decision.”

The application is set to go before the planning committee meeting on Tuesday.

Other links:

BBC’s article

Advertiser: MoD concerns stalls Hondas wind turbine plans

Swindon Advertiser today reported about some MoD holding objections regarding the Wind Turbine development:

An objection from the Ministry of Defence (MoD) has led to the decision over the proposal to build three wind turbines at the Honda plant being delayed.

The MoD has written to Swindon Council to stall the progress of the application, submitted by Honda and sustainable energy firm Ecotricity, so it can be determined whether the turbines will interfere with its radar devices.

The controversial plan to erect three turbines, 120m high at their peak, is now not set to be heard by the council’s planning committee before December at the earliest.

It was originally scheduled to be discussed this month.

An MoD spokesman said: “Wind turbines can affect a number of MoD activities and operations, including air traffic control and threat radars.

“The MoD must do what is necessary to ensure that national security, the safety of aircraft, and, indeed, the safety of aircrew and of people on the ground, are protected through proper safeguarding of those radars.

“All wind farm applications are assessed on a site by site basis.

“The MoD is committed to Government targets for renewable energy and whenever possible we seek to work with wind farm developers to find a mutually acceptable solution.

“The effects of wind turbines on radar are complex and the MoD is working in a number of areas to address the effects of turbines on radar.”

Mike Cheshire, public relations manager for Ecotricity, said the company was aware of the issue and it was not uncommon.

The latest we know is that the MoD is working with BAE systems to look into the issue,” he said.

When they put in an objection it’s often a holding objection rather than them objecting in principle. They are waiting for a technical document to see what is possible. It’s not uncommon for things like this.

“The planning process moves quite slowly and deliberately but that’s so that they can make sure they have got all the evidence in front of them before making a decision.”

The full article is available here.

Advertiser: Turbine protests reaches new heights

Swindon Advertiser today ran an article about last Friday’s blimp flight:

CAMPAIGNERS against the plan for three turbines at the Honda plant managed to beat the wind in their second attempt to demonstrate the potential visual impact on residents.

Protest group Ill Wind suffered a blow last month when strong gales saw their balloon crash to the ground after just a few hours. They had planned for it to fly at 120m to represent the highest height of the proposed wind turbines at the South Marston site.

But yesterday a balloon, which costs £750-a-time to hire, was flying all day, after being given the green light by the Civil Aviation Authority (CAA) and caught the eye of residents even as far afield as Greenbridge.

Neil Burchell, group chairman, said: “There was very little wind so it was up there all day. We’ve had a lot more time to make an impression this time.

“We’ve had a steady stream of people from around the village and many are still so shocked at how high it will be.

“This time we’ve put a marker on the rope to show where the hub will be and that’s been helpful. There seem to be a lot more residents from Stratton as well.

Mr Burchell said the group had sent out around 5,000 leaflets to houses in the two areas since the application came in.

A spokesman for Honda said: “Honda and Ecotricity have already submitted photographs, as stipulated by Swindon Borough Council, to support the planning application which are a true representation of visual impact of the wind turbines.

“However, we do appreciate that it may be difficult to visualise the impact of a turbine from the perspective of each individual resident’s house from the photographs. Honda and Ecotricity also maintain an open communication approach with the community in regards to this proposed wind turbine application.

For anyone who would like to know more about the Honda proposal visit www.ecotricity.co.uk/ honda-swindon or email honda @ecotricity.co.uk.

The full article is available here.

Illwind evidence in response to Honda Letter

In response to Honda & Ecotricity’s letter, IllWind have provided the evidence below which substantiates some of their claims that they have made regarding minimum wind turbine separation:
Read more of this post

Letter from Ecotricity and Honda

Ecotricity LogoThe following letter, dated 8th October 2010, has been provided by Honda and Ecotricity to all South Marston residents:

As you may be aware, Honda in partnership with Ecotricity is proposing to develop three wind turbines at its manufacturing site in Swindon. We previously informed local residents regarding our proposals in June. You may have also seen our advertisements in the local press about our two public information open days, which were attended by over 100 local people and received a good level of local press and radio coverage. Since that time, we have been meeting with local community representatives and answering questions directly with residents as they arise.

Honda and Ecotricity have become increasingly concerned that inaccurate and incomplete information is being circulated which could cause worry and confusion to local residents. Read more of this post

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 114 other followers